You Were Perfect

You did everything you're supposed to
You did everything you should do and say
Certainly, you had to be perfectly perfect
Because you treated me in such a way
You were always the perfect gentleman
And did everything to give me butterflies
You were so concerned for my well being
Because you were "not like other guys"
And, yet, there was something missing
Something we both had left unchecked
For I did not feel those butterflies
Though I knew you were so perfect
I don't think you did anything wrong
You were all you were supposed to be
You're the perfect guy all girls dream of
But I guess your perfect just wasn't for me